The art of peace – can artists stop the war between Israel and Palestine?

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26485/AI/2024/26/12

Keywords:

art, artists, peace, war, fear, death, psychoanalysis, affect, Israel, Palestine

Abstract

In the face of constant threats, regardless of time, epoch, place or degree of civilization (de-civilization), human beings behave in ways that are primarily analyzed by doctors, psychiatrists and psychologists. The most relevant scholars to take up this problem are Lévinas, Ozick and Quignards. Such a state of affairs, involving extreme experiences caused by the forces of nature, technical failures, terrorist acts and wars, has become the object of attention of philosophers, cultural researchers and artists. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict – one of the world’s longest disputes – has been causing deep wounds to communities on both sides. In the midst of political and historical tensions, and the awareness of a lack of any consensus, there is a spring of thought and, consequently, of action, the conviction that art, through the expression of deepest experiences, can become a platform of understanding. The current (since 7 October 2023), another war in the history of the State of Israel since 1948, and the reaction of Israeli and Palestinian artists to it, is the subject of this article. The reaction of artists through works of art is a dramatic attempt to respond to a state of extreme threat (war, death, famine, kidnapping, rape). From the perspective of researchers (e.g. La Capra or Van Alphen), it is perceived as a “transmission of the affect that moves them”, which is reflected in the works created. Jewish and Palestinian artists reacted energetically to the events unfolding in Israel and Gaza. In this article, selected works by Israeli and Palestinian artists will be discussed, among others: Maya Freedman, Hadeel Nasser, Oren Fischer, Michal Worke, Rana Samara and Addam Yekutiel, directly related to current events, and critical philosophical and psychoanalytic commentaries on them. The artists represent a generation born several decades after World War II and 76 years after the establishment of the State of Israel on the territories of former Palestine (British Mandate for Palestine – Mandate territory from 1922 to 1948, formed from parts of the former Ottoman Empire territories in the Middle East), and they live in Israel, Palestine, France and the United States.

References

Alphen Ernst van, Zabawa w Holokaust, “Literatura na Świecie” 2004, no. 1-2, p. 222.

Ariza Sandra Moyano (2020), Affect Theory with Literature and Art : Between and Beyond Representation, in: “Athenea Digital” July 2020, no. 2 (20), e-2319, p. 3.

Bennet Jill (2005), Empathic Vision. Affect, Trauma, and Contemporary Art, Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Birnbaum Natan (1890) Selbstemanzipation!, Vienna (periodical / yearbook; 1885-1894).

Deleuze Gilles, Guattari Felix, What is Philosophy? (1991/1996), transl. from French H. Tomlinson,& G. Burchell, New York: Columbia University Press, p. 164.

Deleuze Gilles (1964), Proust et les signes, Paris: Press Universitaires de France.

Deleuze Gilles (2000), Proust i znaki, transl. Markowski Michał Paweł, Gdańsk: słowo/obraz terytoria.

Ekman Paul, Davidson Richard J. (1994), The nature of emotion: Fundamental questions, Oxford: University Press.

Forgas Joseph Paul (ed.) (2006) Affect in social thinking and Behavior, Psychology Press: Washington 2006.

Greifeneder Rainer (University of Basel), Bless Herbert (University of Mannheim), Fiedler Klaus (University of Heidelberg) (2017) Social Cognition: How Individual Construct Social Realit, New York and Hove: A Psychology Press Books, Routledge.

Gebert Konstanty (2023) Pokój z widokiem na wojnę. Historia Izraela, Warszawa: Agora.

Gilbert Martin (1984) The Arab-Israeli Conflict. Its History in Maps, London: Eidenfeld and Nicholson.

Hartman Geoffrey, Bitburg, “Literatura na Świecie”, 2004, no. 1-2, p. 339.

Jedlińska Eleonora (2019), Kształty pamięci. Wybrane zagadnienia sztuki współczesnej, Łódź: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego.

Keret Etgar (2014), Siedem dobrych lat, transl. Maciejowska Agnieszka, Warszawa: WAB.

Keret Etgar (2016), Tęskniąc za Kissingerem, transl. Maciejowska Agnieszka, Warszawa: WAB.

Keret Etgar (2020), Usterka na skraju galaktyki, transl. Agnieszka Maciejowska, Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie.

Kolańczyk Alina (1999), Świadomość afektu w procesie psychicznym, “Czasopismo Psychologiczne”, 1999, vol. 5, no. 1, p. 43. Sandra Moyano Ariza, Affect Theory with Literature and Art: Between and Beyond Representation, in: “Athenea Digital” July 2020, no. 2 (20), e-2319.

Kubiak Krzysztof (2006), Pierwsza wojna bliskowschodnia 1947-1949. Studium polityczno-wojskowe, Wrocław: Wydawnictwo Naukowe Dolnośląskiej Szkoły Wyższej.

LeDoux Joseph (2000), Mózg emocjonalny. Tajemnicze podstawy życia emocjonalnego, transl. Jankowski Andrzej, Poznań: Media Rodzina 2000.

N. N. (2024), New exhibits at Hostage Square make Tel Aviv Museum a healing space, “The Jerusalem Post” January 21, 2024. Retrieved April 4, 2024.

Nossig Alfred (1887), Próba rozwiązania kwestji żydowskiej, Lwów: Drukarnia Polska.

Oz Amos (2015), Judasz, transl. Kwiatkowski Leszek, Poznań: Rebis.

Oz Amos (2016), Na Ziemi Izraela, transl. Sommer Magdalena, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Czarne.

Ozick Cynthia, Prawa historii i prawa wyobraźni, transl. Batko Zbigniew, “Literatura na Świecie”, 2004, no. 1-2, pp. 81-125.

Said Edward W. (1986), After the last sky: Palestinian lives. London: Faber & Faber.

Said Edward W. (2002), Za ostatnim niebem. Palestyńczycy, transl. Kalinowski Witold, Warszawa: Alethela.

Segev Tom (1999), The Seventh Million. The Israelis and the Holocaust, New York: Hill and Wang.

Segev Tom (1999), One Palestine, Complete. Jews and Arabs Under the British Mandate, New York: Henry Colt and Company.

Segev Tom (2018), Siódmy milion. Izrael – piętno Zagłady, transl. Gadomska Barbara, Warszawa: PWN.

Smoleński Paweł (2021), Balagan. Alfabet izraelski, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Czarne.

Smoleński Paweł (2024), Izrael już nie frunie, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Czarne.

Śliwa Michał, Idea państwa żydowskiego Alfreda Nossiga na tle kształtowania się doktryny syjonizmu politycznego, “Athenaeum. Polskie Studia Politologiczne”, 2018, no. 58, p. 35.

Bennett Jill, Empathic Vision. Affect, Trauma, and Contemporary Art, transl. Mojsak Łukasz. https://www.pismowidok.org/pl/archiwum/2020/26-empatyczne-obrazy/widzenie-empatyczne.-afekt-trauma-i-sztuka-wspolczesna [accessed: 24.04.2024].

Batorski Przemysław, Wizjoner państwa. Theodor Herzl, twórca syjonizmu, https://www.jhi.pl/artykuly/wizjoner-panstwa-theodor-herzl-tworca-syjonizmu,3735 [accessed: 12.04.2024].

Chernick Karen, For many in Israel’s art community, protests have replaced practice, “The Art Newspaper”, 05/04/2024, p. 1. https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2024/04/05/israel-art-communityprotests-hostages-netanyahu-hamas-war [accessed: 29.04.2024].

Fischer Oren, the interview for NHPR (News from New Hampshire). https://www.nhpr.org/2024-01-07/art-and-war-israeli-and-palestinian-artists-reflect-on-oct-7-and-the-crisis-in-gaza [accessed: 29.04.2024].

Kiriłł Fokin, Oto pięć najważniejszych dzieł sztuki o konflikcie izraelsko-palestyńskim. https://kultura.onet.pl/oto-piec-najwazniejszych-dziel-sztuki-o-konflikcie-izraelsko-palestynskim/e62j2xs [accessed: 24.04.2024].

Forgas Joseph Paul, Feeling and Thinking: Affective influences on social cognition, Cambridge University Press, New York 2000; https://www.psychologia-spoleczna.pl/artykuly/197-rola-afektu-wmysleniu-i-relacjach-spolecznych.html?showall=&start=1 [accessed: 20.04.2024].

Freedman Maya and Nasser Hadeel, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/universal-language-art-bader-simon-0s4ec?trk=public_post_main-feed-card_feed-article-content [accessed: 18.03.2024].

Herzl Theodor, Der Judenstaat: Versuch einer modernen Lösung der Judenfrage, Public domain in the USA, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/28865 [accessed: 12.04.2024].

Samara Rana, the interview for NHPR (News from New Hampshie). https://www.nhpr.org/2024-01-07/art-and-war-israeli-and-palestinian-artists-reflect-on-oct-7-and-the-crisis-in-gaza [accessed: 29. 04.2024].

Wasilewski Karol (ed.), Nowacka Sara, Wojnarowicz Michał, Zaręba Szymon, Konflikt wczoraj. Report of the Polish Institute of International Affairs: Konflikt izraelsko-palestyński 2020: rok złego przełomu. Warszawa 2020. https://www.pism.pl/upload/images/artykuly/c30b634a-9d56-4732-88f2-ee3dccd78e05/1593524372457.pdf [accessed: 20.04.2024].

White Tamara, The Universal Language of Art, (11 March 2024). https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/universal-language-art-bader-simon-0s4ec?trk=public_post_main-feed-card_feed-articlecontent [accessed: 29.04.2024].

Worke Michal, the interview for NHPR (News from New Hampshire). https://www.nhpr.org/2024-01-07/art-and-war-israeli-and-palestinian-artists-reflect-on-oct-7-and-the-crisis-in-gaza [accessed: 29.04.2024].

Yekutieli Addam – interview for NHPR (News from New Hampshire). https://www.nhpr.org/2024-01-07/art-and-war-israeli-and-palestinian-artists-reflect-on-oct-7-and-the-crisis-in-gaza [accessed: 29.04.2024].

https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-release/2023/10/gaza-un-experts-decry-bombing-hospitals-andschools-against-humanity [accessed: 17.04.2024].

https://zpe.gov.pl/a/konflikty-zbrojne-we-wspolczesnym-swiecie/DtXFbf0BZ [accessed: 17.04.2024].

https://www.thefreelibrary.com/%22Trauma%22%3a+Dundee+Contemporary+Arts.+(Dundee%2c+Scotland).-a080856223 [accessed: 24.04.2024].

Downloads

Published

2024-12-29